| 
View
 

Models of Reading Comprehension

This version was saved 15 years, 6 months ago View current version     Page history
Saved by fran toomey
on June 6, 2009 at 11:23:10 am
 

COMPARISON OF MODELS OF READING COMPREHENSION  Explorience, 2006 Revised 10/06 ©

Scobie and Toomey2 (97-06)

To enable students to use their knowledge for higher order thinking

Judith Irwin l991

Strategies that Work

Harvey/Goudvis, 2000

 

Carlisle 2002

CRISS 1996

 

 

Self Management (Sm)

^Recognizing breakdowns

^Identifying type/source of breakdown

^Repairing breakdown with strategies and monitoring success

Metacognition

^comprehension monitoring

^adjusting strategies

^study skills

^Repair faulty comprehension

^Monitory the adequacy of understanding

Executive Strategies (4)

^recognize breakdowns

^decide how to approach task

 

Sticky notes

Pre and post journal?

Identifying purpose (P)

^Reason for Reading Text

(A) Information, (B) How to use

 

Who determines purpose:

*Teacher, Author, Reader

 

Questioning (2)

Preparatory Strategies(l)

^Determine purpose

^Make predictions

Pre and Post Journal

Organizing the Information (O)

*Text Structure (8 basic types)

*Graphic Organizers

*Text Features

*Genres

Macroprocessing

^Organize text structure

^summarizing

Determining Importance:  Distilling the Essence of Text (5)

 

Organizational Strategies (2)

^Identify Main Idea

^Summarize

^Map text structure

*Cohesion Ties between Sentences

*Genre/Text Structure Instruction

Text Structure

Main Idea and Details

Graphic Organizers

Summarizing

Organizing for learning

Selective Underlining

Power Notes; Two column notes

Content frames

Story Plans

 Knowledge Building (K)

^Identify Concepts

^Define Concepts

^Perceive and Construct Relationships among Concepts

Microprocessing

^chunking

^microselection

Making Connections (1)

Determining Importance:  Distilling the Essence of Text (5))

 

Preparatory

^Access prior knowledge

*Word learning strategies

Concept Mapping

KWL

Elaborating  (E)

Connecting

Imagining,

Critiquing

 

 

Integrative Processes

^Connections

^Slot filling inferences

^Anaphora inferences

Elaborative processes?

^prediction

^mental imagery

^affective responses

^Higher level thinking

Making Inferences (4)

Elaborative Strategies (3)

^integrating prior knowledge to form images

^Generate explanations that extend text info

 

Stop and Record (Sr)

*Listing important concepts

*Use of graphic organizer

*Concept Mapping

Leads to Summary Writing

 

Visualizing (3)

Synthesizes information (6)

 

 

Think pair share

Sticky notes for discussion

Read and say something

Comments (0)

You don't have permission to comment on this page.